The Sweet Side of Elizabeth
When summer heat settles over Union County, residents of Elizabeth head for something cold and sweet. Families stroll after dinner for soft-serve cones, shoppers at The Mills at Jersey Gardens grab a treat between stores, and supermarkets keep freezer aisles stocked with premium pints. Ice cream is a universal pleasure that crosses every culture in this diverse city, from Latin American paletas to Italian gelato.
Here are the ten ice cream brands that Elizabeth residents love most, whether enjoyed at a local shop or scooped at home.
The Top 10 Ice Cream Brands in Elizabeth
1. Carvel
Carvel is a beloved tri-state tradition. Its soft-serve ice cream cakes, featuring the iconic chocolate crunchies layer, have been the centerpiece of countless birthday parties. Characters like Fudgie the Whale and Cookie Puss are nostalgic favorites, and Carvel cakes are widely available in local supermarkets and franchise shops.
2. Rita's Italian Ice and Frozen Custard
Rita's is a summertime staple across New Jersey, famous for its Italian ice, creamy frozen custard, and layered Gelati. The tradition of free Italian ice on the first day of spring draws long, cheerful lines. Its refreshing, fruity flavors are perfect for hot afternoons.
3. Dairy Queen
Dairy Queen's signature Blizzard, mixed so thick it is served upside down, remains one of the most iconic frozen desserts in America. DQ also offers dipped cones, sundaes, and ice cream cakes, making it a reliable family destination.
4. Baskin-Robbins
Known for its 31 flavors concept, Baskin-Robbins encourages customers to try something new every day of the month. Its rotating flavor of the month, colorful sundaes, and customizable ice cream cakes keep the experience fresh for kids and adults alike.
5. Cold Stone Creamery
Cold Stone Creamery turns ice cream into a performance by mixing toppings on a frozen granite stone. Customers can choose signature creations or build their own, making it a fun outing for families and groups of friends.
6. Ben & Jerry's
Ben & Jerry's is famous for chunky, creative flavors such as Cherry Garcia, Half Baked, and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. The brand is equally known for its social mission and commitment to fair trade ingredients. Its pints are a freezer staple in Elizabeth households.
7. Häagen-Dazs
Created in the Bronx, just across the river, Häagen-Dazs pioneered the American super-premium ice cream category. It is prized for its rich texture and short ingredient lists. Classic flavors like vanilla bean, dulce de leche, and coffee resonate strongly with Elizabeth's Latin American and European communities.
8. Breyers
Breyers has been a family freezer favorite for generations, known for its smooth texture and accessible pricing. Its wide range includes classic flavors, reduced-sugar options, and dairy-free varieties, making it a practical choice for large families.
9. Talenti
Talenti offers gelato and sorbetto in its distinctive clear jars. Inspired by Italian traditions, its dense, creamy texture and flavors like sea salt caramel and Sicilian pistachio appeal to those who appreciate gelato. The reusable jars are an added bonus.
10. Van Leeuwen
Born in Brooklyn, Van Leeuwen makes French-style ice cream with extra egg yolks for a luxurious custard base, along with a celebrated line of oat milk vegan ice creams. Its adventurous limited-edition flavors attract food enthusiasts across the region.
Finding the Right Ice Cream for Every Occasion
Birthday parties: Carvel and Dairy Queen ice cream cakes are classic crowd-pleasers. Hot summer days: Rita's Italian ice offers light refreshment. A night in: Ben & Jerry's, Häagen-Dazs, and Talenti pints satisfy indulgent cravings. Dietary needs: Van Leeuwen and Breyers offer vegan and reduced-sugar options. Family outings: Cold Stone and Baskin-Robbins turn dessert into an experience.
Elizabeth's Cultural Frozen Treats
Beyond national brands, Elizabeth's neighborhoods offer culturally rich frozen desserts. Mexican paleterías serve fruit and cream paletas in flavors like mango, tamarind, and coconut. Italian bakeries in Peterstown offer gelato and spumoni, while Brazilian shops feature açaí bowls. These local treats complement the brands above perfectly.
Ice Cream Trends in 2026
Plant-based and dairy-free ice creams continue to expand, with oat, almond, and coconut bases becoming mainstream. Global flavors such as ube, black sesame, guava, and horchata are increasingly common. High-protein and low-sugar options are also popular among health-conscious consumers who still want an indulgent treat.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between ice cream, gelato, and frozen custard?
Ice cream typically contains more cream and air. Gelato uses more milk, less air, and is served slightly warmer for a dense, silky texture. Frozen custard includes egg yolks, giving it an extra rich, smooth consistency.
Are there good dairy-free ice cream options?
Yes. Brands such as Van Leeuwen, Ben & Jerry's, and Breyers offer dairy-free lines made with oat milk, almond milk, or coconut cream, and Rita's Italian ice is naturally dairy-free in many flavors.
When is the best season for ice cream shops in Elizabeth?
Seasonal shops are busiest from late spring through early fall, while national chains and supermarket brands are available year-round.
Conclusion
Whether you crave a nostalgic Carvel cake, a refreshing Rita's ice, or a luxurious pint of Häagen-Dazs, Elizabeth offers endless ways to enjoy ice cream. Explore the brands on this list, sample the city's cultural specialties, and discover your new favorite scoop.
